Auto Accident Calculator – Your Real Out-of-Pocket Cost

Auto Accident Calculator - MarkCalc

Auto Accident Calculator

Last updated: August 22, 2026

This isn't a settlement value estimator — it adds up what an accident actually cost you out of your own pocket: deductible, unreimbursed repairs, missed work, medical copays, and the ripple effect on your insurance premium.

This tool gives a rough educational estimate only. It is not financial or legal advice. Actual costs depend on your specific policy and circumstances.
Total Out-of-Pocket Cost
0

Why "out-of-pocket cost" is a different question from "settlement value"

A settlement calculator answers "what am I owed?" This calculator answers a more personal, budgeting-focused question: "what has this accident actually cost me, regardless of what I eventually get paid back?" The two numbers can look very different.

Costs that often slip through the cracks

  • Deductibles — paid before any insurance payout, and rarely reimbursed unless the other driver's insurer covers your claim.
  • Partial wage replacement — PIP or employer sick pay often covers only a percentage of lost income, leaving a gap.
  • Rate increases — even accidents that aren't your fault can sometimes affect renewal pricing depending on your insurer and state.
  • Time and inconvenience — not captured in dollar terms here, but real: time spent on calls, repair shop visits, and paperwork.

How the premium impact is estimated

Added Cost = Current Premium × Increase % × Years

This spreads a percentage rate increase over the number of years it typically stays on your policy, giving a rough sense of the accident's cost beyond the immediate expenses.

Frequently asked questions
Why isn't my full deductible always reimbursed?+
If you use your own collision coverage, you typically pay the deductible upfront. It's only reimbursed if the at-fault driver's insurer accepts liability and pays your insurer back through subrogation — which isn't guaranteed or immediate.
Will my rates go up even if the accident wasn't my fault?+
It depends on your state and insurer. Many places restrict "not at fault" surcharges, but some insurers still factor any accident into future pricing — check your policy or ask your agent directly.
What if I don't know my exact repair costs yet?+
Use your best estimate from a repair shop quote. You can always re-run this calculator once you have final figures to see how the total out-of-pocket cost changes.
Does PIP cover 100% of lost wages?+
Rarely. Most PIP policies cover a percentage (often 70-80%) of lost income up to a policy cap, leaving a gap that this calculator accounts for separately.
Should I include this out-of-pocket total in a settlement demand?+
Documented out-of-pocket costs can support a settlement demand, especially deductibles and unreimbursed expenses tied directly to the accident. Keep receipts and records for anything you plan to claim.
MC
MarkCalc Team
Tool built and maintained by MarkCalc
This calculator is built and maintained by the MarkCalc team to help estimate the personal, out-of-pocket side of an accident, separate from settlement value. It is intended for general estimation only.